American Idol Top 6!
This week on American Idol the Top 6 will be performing songs from Carole King’s catalog which should prove very interesting and exciting.
Based on the votings in the past weeks, Jacob and Haley would be two of the the bottom three this week. Who else would join them? If Scotty did not learn from the mistake he made last week, he would very well be in the bottom three this week!
I think that is what makes some of the comments so frustrating.
“Okay” radio voices: Lauren and Scotty.
Not good for radio voices: Casey and Jacob.
Listen to the Itunes tracks and just LISTEN. Forget the performances and their faces and just LISTEN to the voices. This is what will determine if these artists will sell albums or not after AI Season 10 is done. Simon always said: “I can hear that on the radio….”. It’s the radio that matters.
Country fans can vote for Scotty 1000 times each and not change the fact he’s predictable, quite boring and really not that “radio ready”. He may win this contest, but my eyes are on Haley, Lauren, James and Stefano for people who will sell records.
8 songs of Scotty swaggering through dreary old country tunes? Wow. Watching paint dry suddenly has appeal for me.
Jacob
Stefano
Scotty(I’m a fan of his, but he needs a wake up call)
Going home
Either Jacob or Stefano. Sorry but these two just really bore me to tears.
Scotty’s fan base is faltering and James is stealing them as fast as you can say IDOL.
Scotty needs to think long and hard about his “if it ain’t broke don’t fix it” approach. It may not be broke, but if it’s boring your fans, you can go from top pick for AI10 to “bye bye”. Just ask Pia – a favorite of many fans and the judges, especially in the first weeks.
Then GONE. Just like a country song: Wake up one morning and the job, the house, the girl, the truck, and even the dog… ALL GONE!
For now on I’m goimg to call him King James
Of the 18 that have made the final two, 9 of them appeared in the bottom 3 at one point or the other.
In only two years have the final 2 not appeared in the bottom 3 (or 2 in the semis) and they were the two David’s in Season 7 and Lee and Crystal last year.
Both Kris Allen and Adam Lambert were in the bottom 3 once in Season 8.
In Season 6 only Jordin Sparks escaped the bottom 3 as did Taylor Hicks (5) and Carrie Underwood (4).
None of Season 3’s finalists escaped the bottom 3 and Fantasia was in it twice but won.
Ruben Studdard was actually in the bottom 2 once but Clay Aiken was never in the bottom 3.
Kelly Clarkson also did not appear in the bottom 3.
So Ruben, Fantasia and Kris Allen all won after being in the bottom 3 at least once.
No-one who has been given the save since it started 3 seasons ago has got to the final three.
They are James, Lauren & Scotty.
I hope Jacob is voted off next, I dont like his attitude and I’m tired of his style of singing. He makes me wanna shoot myself.
Casey 1/2 half was really good
Haley I dont usually like her, but that was her best performance
Scotty – don’t like country, usually love him, but this was his worst performance
Stefano – much better but heavy on the cheese
Jacob – ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZz
Lauren – ditto
Bottom 3: Jacob, Lauren and either Stefano or Casey
Going Buh-Bye – Jacob